Mixing All My Liquid & Cream Highlighters!

I’m finally doing it!

I’ve delayed this post so many times because I was waiting for nearly a month and a half for something to arrive from eBay, and then when I finally got it, I didn’t have the time to film this.

I decided to separate my liquid and cream highlighters from my powder ones because I feel like they’re nearly the same consistency (wet). Next week I’ll be posting my “Mixing All My Powder Highlighters”. Let’s get started!! πŸ™‚

EDIT: Credit for this idea goes to Safiya Nygaard, who I believe started this “Mixing My Makeup” trend. Correct me if I’m wrong please! πŸ™‚


Liquid & Cream Highlighters Used:


  • City Color Glow Duo Cream/Powder Highlighter
  • NYX Born to Glow Liquid Illuminator in Sun Beam
  • NYX Wonder Stick Highlight & Contour in Universal
  • NYX Bright Idea Illuminating Stick in Lavender Lust
  • Jelly Pong Pong All Over Glow Luminizer Gel
  • TEMPTU S/B Highlighter in Champagne Shimmer
  • The Beauty Crop Lighting Crew Highlight Cream

Watch me mix my highlighters, swatching it and trying it on:

Results + First Impressions:

You can see that it looks really pink in the pot and I actually expected that. I have a lot of highlighters with pink undertones, and though I don’t feel like they suit me that well, they are still very pretty. This highlighter came out a little thick but I also expected that to happen since I was mixing liquids and creams.


I liked how it looked on my face, it looked frosty white when the light hit it directly, but if I looked straight ahead, I could see a slightly pinky strip across my cheek bone due to the strong pink undertones, but I don’t mind it as much because it’s actually quite subtle.

MOTDs + Swatches:

As you’ll see in the swatches below, certain lighting CAN bring out those pink undertones, which were a pain to catch in photos, but they’re subtle and I’m sure I can pull off this highlighter if I don’t use too much, and blend it well.

Note: All of these swatches + MOTDs are under natural lighting, artificial (cool fluorescent), and warm.


Most of the highlighters I have do* have golden shimmer, and even though the blended swatch doesn’t show those gold reflects very well under other lights, warm lighting does an amazing job at bringing out those golden tones.


* * *


I wasn’t able to get a good angle of the highlight, but it still looked pretty good and almost natural. In my opinion, the natural light brought out a little bit of the pink undertones, but it also looked a little lavender. The NYX Bright Idea Illuminating Stick is probably responsible for that.


* * *

Cool Fluorescent:

I feel like the highlight looks the best under this kind of light. It looks like a frosty white, super pigmented highlighter, and I really liked how it looked on the skin. When facing away from the light though, you can see the pink undertones, so it looks like a pinky stripe over my cheekbone, but it’s very subtle.


I love how different lighting brings out different undertones in the highlight, it’s amazing that it can look so different but it’s very pretty regardless of lighting. I’m seriously considering on fully testing this highlighter and then giving you an in-depth review (if that’s even possible) on how it performs, but not unless you guys might want to see that too. I had so much fun doing this and I got a really pretty highlighter out of it.

Have you guys done this challenge yet?
If not, would you??


Find me on social media:

Instagram | Twitter | YouTubeΒ | Pinterest

28 thoughts on “Mixing All My Liquid & Cream Highlighters!

  1. The mixture turned out really well! I would definitely keep it around as go-to highlighter because it has so much definition! I’m looking forward to the powder highlighter combination! Great post love!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Oh my gosh, Rossy! What a fun experiment. How satisfying was it to break off chunks of makeup like that?!?

    The highlighter turned out so well & it really does look beautiful on you!! Can’t wait to see the powder mix!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. It was very fun indeed, all the mixing I mean haha. It almost broke my heart to ruin the cream ones and it was even worse when I did the powder ones BUT I got over it and I feel like they went into making something awesome LOL
      Thank you!! πŸ™‚ I thought the shade was really gorgeous πŸ™‚ I cannot wait to use it some more πŸ™‚

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Yes, but you have so many you probably would never have used ’em all! I would love to destroy makeup. πŸ˜€
        By the way, I would love to read a more in-depth review of how your creation works out. ❀

        Liked by 1 person

        1. Exactly, which is why I can’t keep buying makeup I already have..it’s so so tempting though! Like the physician’s formula butter highlighter…I WANT IT! LMAO
          I will keep that in mind and keep testing it out πŸ™‚

          Liked by 1 person

    1. I haven’t seen the videos where they mix foundations and concealers yet, I don’t even have enough to do that haha.
      But yeah, the highlighter turned out so pretty!


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s