Influenster — Benefit Cosmetics Precisely, My Brow Pencil Review

Heyy dolls!

I got this eyebrow pencil a very long time ago, I believe over the summer. I just never wrote a blog post on it because I wasn’t required to. It’s my current go-to brow product so I thought I could review this for you guys today.

This brow pencil replaced an old favorite, the IT Cosmetics Brow Power, and for all the right reasons! I have been using this product consistently for the last 6 months or so. It is also the one I used in my eyebrow routine video:


Let’s get started!

Disclosure: I received this product complimentary from Influenster for testing purposes.


Product Description from Benefit Cosmetics:

Oh my WOW…precise & defined eyebrows! This ultra-fine eyebrow pencil draws incredibly natural-looking, hair-like strokes that last 12 budge-proof hours.* A few strokes of the rich yet blendable color will transform brows from shapeless & undefined to filled & defined eyebrows. Includes signature Tips & Tricks.

Size: 0.08 g Net wt. 0.002 oz. / Price: $24 USD


I love the packaging, it’s very beautiful and different than your average eyebrow pencil. It’s very sturdy and it has a short, ridge-like section where you can easily grip it if you want more precision. I personally hold it further out because I like to start lightly. I find that the closer I am to the tip, the darker I draw on my eyebrows, and I don’t always like that.


I also love the spoolie end, this one is the softest I have ever come across so right off the bat I could tell that this is a high-quality product. It’s very well made.

Formula & Application

The formula is quite nice and the ultra-fine tip makes filling in my brows an easy task. I have this pencil in the shade 4 and while it is medium, it comes quite close to my actual hair color. Although, it has a slight orange tint which is more noticeable when I fill in my brows a lot darker.


When I draw my eyebrows lightly, I don’t need to use a fiber gel on top to cancel out those orange tones. Most days when I use it I don’t need to hide the tones because they don’t show up as much.

This pencil is so easy to use. It draws natural brows and the fine tip is perfect for precision and for hair-like strokes. It wears well too, I’d agree that it lasts 12 hours, possibly even longer. One more thing I love is that it doesn’t lose its shape like most eyebrow pencils, so that’s a huge plus!


Pros & Cons:


  • Sturdy packaging
  • Ultra-fine tip
  • Easy application
  • Natural, hair-like strokes
  • Lasts 12+ hours
  • Keeps its shape
  • Good for beginners (but pricey!)


  • A bit pricey!
  • Brand is not cruelty-free

I would repurchase if it wasn’t for the price and non-CF status of the brand, but the product itself is stellar! Either way, this is my current go-to product, I use it pretty much every single day and I’m coming close to finishing it, which I’m not looking forward to.


It’s such an easy to use product. I’ve only tried a handful of eyebrow pencils but this one has been my favorite so far, I almost consider it my holy-grail of brow products.

Has anyone else used this eyebrow pencil? What did you think?
Do you know of any dupes that might replace this one?


Find me on social media:

Instagram | Twitter | YouTube | Pinterest

Disclosure: I received this product complimentary from Influenster for testing purposes. This review is a personal opinion and is honest. I did not receive compensation besides the product to try.

12 thoughts on “Influenster — Benefit Cosmetics Precisely, My Brow Pencil Review

  1. I think your brows are lovely as is. They’re such a nice shape! My brows suck. They’re shaped like sperm. LOL! Seriously… they’re like fatter toward the middle of my face and thin on the ends. I usually use a powder or cream with a brush when I want to fill mine in, but I might have to try this sometime.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Aww thanks. I only like one of my brows, the other is very sparse in the middle. Hairs no longer grow in certain areas so as much as I try to grow them out it doesn’t work lol.
      I like how you fill in your brows though! And I would recommend this if you’re willing to spend $24 for it, otherwise, I’m sure there are more affordable ones that come to this. A lot of people say colourpop and nyx have good brow pencils.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I always see this product on the benefit counter but haven’t tried it myself, it’s amazing that it actually does what it says and lasts 12 hours though, how good is that? Great review Rossy, thanks for sharing!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. It’s pricey, but if you’re willing to spend the cash, I’d recommend it! And yeah, several times I’ve wiped my brow by accident thinking “ooh no I rubbed it off!” but I check and it’s still there. Although, I don’t know if it’s the fiber gel or the clear brow mascara I put on top, but either way, it lasts and I love it! I forgot to mention it but it did really well during the summer as well 🙂


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s